-
“Memoirists like Katha Pollitt and Elizabeth Hayt historically receive worse reviews than their confessional male counterparts, one author alleged, stirring up the literary blogosphere.” What do you all think? Yes/no?
-
“Scandinavian crime fiction may still be something of a novelty act in the UK, but it’s a well-established genre in the rest of Europe, particularly Germany and France. So how come we got left behind? Put it down to that old national weakness for effortless superiority combined with instinctive parochialism.” (via @globebooks)
Jan 242009
Westminster Abby by Micol Ostow
Publication: Puffin (2005), Paperback, 192 pages / ISBN 0142404136
Genre: Teen Fiction
Rating: 1.5/5
Find @ Amazon
I picked this up because a) the cover is awesome (done by Yuko) and b) it’s about a girl who goes off to live in a boarding school in London. I love books that take place in boarding schools! Unfortunately, I didn’t love this book. It took way too long to read for such a short book, and that was because it was horribly, horribly boring.
Westminster Abby is the first book in the S.A.S.S. series: Students Across the Seven Seas (love that name, actually). This one takes place in London and stars Abby, a plain vanilla kind of gal who nevertheless wants to spice things up in her life. She’s just broken up with her cheating boyfriend, James, and wants to get away from both him and her overbearing, overprotective parents. What better place to find a new Abby and a new life than in a foreign country?
One thing this book does well is describe London. The streets, the pubs, the shops: all neatly laid out for readers, and without ever going into too much detail. That’s pretty much the only thing I did like, however.
I never connected with the characters, and in fact thought the potential new boyfriend, Ian, was a creepy user who just wanted to have a fling with an American chick. When it turned out he was sincere, I didn’t buy it. I also never really liked Abby, though I did appreciate that she eventually found her own self and voice, especially against her crazily-involved-with-her-life parents. And James-the-ex? Came off as gay. Whoops.
I also didn’t buy most of the vocabulary used by the characters. Okay, maybe I could see straight-A, overachieving student Abby using words like “perennial” in her conversations, but no way am I buying that punk rock rebel Zoe uses words like “extrapolate” outside of school papers. And while I’m at it, a lot of the dialogue seemed really…too perfect. Like the characters were reading from a script, instead of actually speaking to each other.
Also, I know it’s a teen book and everything, but I can’t believe that sex wasn’t mentioned even in passing. Not even the boys say anything! And Abby and her ex stay in a hostel room together, alone, in another city! And no-one was worried about possible hanky-panky? Abby wasn’t even worried about the possibility of James wanting to do her? I worried about it more than the characters did! To completely ignore this area of teen life was bothersome and, well, incorrect.
So while it’s a bit like a sitcom, where everything is perfectly imperfect and all problems are solved by the time the credits roll, it’s also rather sweet and innocent. (Like, say, Leave It To Beaver.) Abby’s ex used to make her playlists, for Pete’s sake. It’s not dangerous and it’s not really exciting, but it is a place where you what’s going to happen and what the moral is. I suppose everyone wants a bit of certainty in their lives, even vanilla teenagers. I’d just like something a little more than that.
(Each SASS book is written by a different author, so it’s feasible that another book might be better. Should I check it out?)
Other reviews: Frenetic Reader | Bookworm Sarah | That Teen Can Blog!
Loading ...
